Meet Our Team

We're the ones who help you at Blue River Insurance Group

Together, we boldly and proudly advocate for your best outcomes and help you find solutions to the challenges you face. We leverage all of our considerable resources to deliver you a refreshing and memorably positive client experience.

insurance agency in Shelbyville, Indiana

Lindel Smith


After graduating from Indiana University – Bloomington in 2013 with a Bachelor of Science in Informatics, Lindel started his career in the industry as a Material Damage Adjuster in a claims department processing all lines of property & casualty insurance. Seeing claims on a regular basis involving families, who were uneducated and uninformed about their coverage and underinsured limits, he decided to open Blue River Insurance Group in June 2020. He enjoys educating his clients and prospects about coverages and policy language to help them make informed decisions regarding their policies. He values transparency and developing long lasting relationships.

Lindel is a die-hard fan of hockey and the St. Louis Blues. He grew up in Shelbyville, IN and currently resides in New Palestine, IN with his fiancée and son.

Olivia Garcia | Blue River Insurance Group | Shelbyville, IN

Olivia Garcia

Business Development Officer

In addition to assisting Lindel with business development for Blue River Insurance Group, Olivia is a full-time mom and mortgage loan officer.

With an unwavering passion for business expansion and forging connections, Olivia will spearhead our strategic initiatives to create new partnerships and explore untapped markets. Her expertise lies in identifying emerging trends and new clients, and leveraging opportunities to propel our organization forward.

Olivia possesses a proven track record of delivering exceptional client satisfaction. Creating new relationships, while nurturing the existing ones, is something that comes seamlessly to her.

Blue River Insurance Group: An Independent Insurance Agency

Let's Have A Conversation

Schedule your Discovery Call below. We'll get acquainted and work to understand your needs and preferences. Then, we'll build a custom program that protects you, your business, your family, and your livelihood.