Insurance Agency based in Shelbyville, Indiana

Get Better Coverage & Better Rates With Blue River Insurance Group

Finding the best combination of insurance coverage and cost can be a daunting task. It's why we make the process simple, and explain coverages in terms you can understand, so you know exactly how your money is being spent.

Quick Quotes & Service

We know your time is valuable which is why we're super quick, yet thorough with everything we do for you.

Choice Of Carriers

We proactively shop the insurance market place to find you the best combination of cost and coverage.

Technology Focused

Our agency utilizes technology specialized for the insurance industry to provide you with the client & service experience you deserve.

Why Choose Blue River Insurance Group?

Blue River Insurance Group - Shelbyville, IN

At Blue River Insurance Group, our staff will have your best interests in mind and treat you as if you were family. We will bring that same approach when helping you choose the right policy and coverages and will always strive to deliver the best possible client experience.

You won't just be sold a policy and never hear from us again. We will continue to nurture our relationship long after choosing a policy and be available to have conversations. We will provide our expert advice, so you can find peace of mind with your decisions regarding your insurance needs. Blue River Insurance Group enjoys building long lasting relationships and, we promise to provide exceptional and dependable service to our clients.


YouTube video

Client Testimonials

For every five star Google review, Blue River Insurance Group donates $5 to charity. 

Insurance Blog

people holding keys

5 Rules Every Landlord Should Live By

I’m pretty confident that if you asked anyone who has ever owned a rental property you would get an overwhelming response that it’s not as lucrative or easy as they thought it would be. In fact, owning a rental property can be a major pain, and end up costing you a ton of money! I…

family playing with daughter

Will My Credit Rating Change My Insurance Rates?

I was recently asked this question by one of our Blue River Insurance Group clients, and thought I would share the answer here for our readers. There are a lot of things that go into homeowners and auto insurance rates, one of them being credit. I’ve heard a lot of complaints from people who don’t like…

car crash

Why Do My Auto Insurance Rates Keep Going Up Even Though My Car Keeps Getting Older?

Why do my auto insurance rates keep going up even though my car is getting older?  At Blue River Insurance Group, many of our clients ask this question so I would like to address it from a couple of angles. First things first, even though it’s called car/auto insurance, it covers more than just your…


Our process is simple. Start online, and we'll reach
out to complete your coverage comparison

Our team of friendly insurance advisors is here to make the process of finding the best
coverage simple. Start a conversation with us today.

  • Start Online

    Enter basic info on our website

  • We Compare Carriers

    We shop multiple carriers for you

  • You Choose

    Pick the coverage package you like best